July / 2001
"Kentucky Joe" Rodger Bingham

by: Dorothy Johnston

Rodger Bingham may not have won the $1 million on Survivor II, but he put the small town of Crittenden on the map.

When Rodger Bingham secured a spot on Survivor II-the popular CBS television show about real folks competing for a $1 million prize in the Australian Outback-no one in Crittenden could have predicted that the encounter would eventually spawn a media superstar, a press frenzy, and a new mecca on the northern Kentucky cultural landscape.
But it did.
If Crittenden was formerly known for anything beyond Grant County, it was the B&E Restaurant, inconspicuously perched beside I-75 midway between Florence and Dry Ridge. The B&E is home to Edna Cummins' coveted coconut cream pies. And it's where Rodger has eaten breakfast every morning at precisely 6:30 since the diner opened 18 years ago.
With the onslaught of Survivor fever, Outback souvenirs have carved a niche on the B&E bill of fare, right alongside country-cured ham. And they are gobbled up just as fast.
"I had magnets that said 'Where Rodger Eats Breakfast,' " says Cummins, the "E" of B&E. "We went through 500 of those little suckers in a week.
"It's 'Rodgerism,' that's how big it's become. We had a lady from Rhode Island come in and say 'Is this where Rodger eats?' People come in and sit in the chair where Rodger sits and have their pictures taken. I could get my camera and charge $5 a whack and Rodger doesn't even have to be here."
At times it's been hectic, even overwhelming, she says. "There's been an awful lot of interest in our little town. The producers told Rodger it would turn Crittenden upside down. Nobody even knew we existed before. Now they want to know all about us.
"This place has been like Grand Central Station. The girls think it'll all go back to normal…sorry, I tell them, I don't think so."
In spite of incremental inconveniences, there's been a whole lot of good, Cummins says.
"If you knew Rodger, there was absolutely no difference after Survivor. But he has done something he didn't expect to do. He has pulled the county together."
Rodger teaches industrial arts at Grant County High in Dry Ridge, but he resides in Crittenden, so both towns can legitimately claim him as their own.
After filming was complete, Rodger returned home and to teaching but was restricted from discussing the show due to an agreement with CBS since the episodes were currently being aired.
"We ate lunch with Rodger before he was known by his single name," says Cheryl Workman, a special education teacher at Grant County High. "There's Madonna, Cher, Elvis…and now there's Rodger.
"We sat at a big round table in the lunchroom, and we would ask him questions about what we thought might happen on the show, and he would say 'Hmm…,' and pretend not to know. But I would try to read him when he did it. Everyone did."
People pull off the interstate in hopes of a Rodger sighting, says Beth Glenn, a customer service representative for Owen Electric cooperative in Crittenden.
"Rodger is on our electric service and Rodger has consumed our county," says Glenn. "My daughter lost her wallet at the Florence Cinema and the guy who found it had one question to ask, 'Do you know Rodger?' But it's all just fun the way Rodger looks at it, and he'll just be the same old Rodger."
Fortunately he was the same old Rodger even without the conveniences of modern-day Kentucky living, like electricity and running water.
"That's one of the reasons I stuck around so long," Rodger says. Out of 16 contestants, Rodger was the 12th to be ousted. "It surprised me when not one of them (the Kucha Tribe as Rodger's team was known on Survivor II) knew how to light a lantern. I thought everybody knew how to live without a light bulb.
"I still get a little chuckle when I think of them trying to grab ahold of the chickens. The Kucha Tribe carried on the most serious conversation about how to get them out of the coop. It's pretty simple, you just open the door."
But living in the Australian Outback wasn't a joke, says Rodger, who was nicknamed "Kentucky Joe" by his teammates.
"The survivor element became very real when we went 34 hours with nothing to eat. At CBS, they kept stressing the circumstances of our game were more challenging than the first Survivor show.
"The network people thought I would be a quitter. But they wanted someone from a small town, someone involved in religion, and they liked my accent. They said, 'You started in the banking business, then mobile homes, then farming, and now you're a school teacher. You're taking the easy way out.'
"I told them they didn't know me. I told them if I wanted to quit tomorrow, I could be making twice as much money in banking as in teaching school. Then Mark Burnett, the executive producer, who liked me from the beginning, told the board, 'There's the answer you were looking for.' "
Everyone in Crittenden is supremely proud of Rodger, says long-time friend and neighbor Carolyn Lowry.
"He has been flabbergasted by how everyone has responded," she says. "But the true joy for him is that he is in the teaching profession, and the show has mesmerized the kids. They knew he was a great teacher, but they didn't know how really strong Rodger is."
Fifty finalists (narrowed from 49,000 to 800 to the final 50) took a 1,500-question psychological test, Rodger says. "They try to read your mind. They try to figure how you will play the game as a team member, and still try to win the $1 million prize for yourself. It's tough, but I've always felt that being able to get along with different personalities and being able to read people are my biggest assets.
"I did the worst on the memory challenge, the one I thought I'd do the best on. We hadn't eaten in 34 hours, and I was weak and tired. But I still feel like if Mike (a Survivor member who burned his hands and had to be air-lifted off the island) had stayed, I could have won."
Rodger has put Kentucky on the map in a positive way, says Workman. "One afternoon, we were eating at the Country Grill across from the school, and some people were staring at him. He just got up, and went over to them, and said 'How are you folks today?' He didn't have to do that."